Op-ed views and opinions expressed are solely those of the author.
By creating the “Disinformation Governance Board” the Biden administration has taken a long step backward to seventeenth century England when freedom of press and speech did not exist. Are we on the verge of resurrecting the ancient charge of “seditious libel” where even truth is libelous and punishable as the cancel culture has ably demonstrated?
It was not by accident that the first amendment guarantees freedom of speech and “the free exercise of religion” as both marched together on the road to greater liberty in the English-Speaking world. Seventeenth century poet John Milton’s pamphlet “Aeropagitica”1644), argued against censorship and prior licensing on the grounds that men could decide between truth and error for themselves, this at a time of intense religious ferment and the English Civil War which pitched Puritans against the crown and the established Anglican Church. The Puritans though were not friends of religious freedom. That notion was a product of the fertile mind of Roger Williams, founder of Rhode Island and “the Providence Plantations”. For men like Milton and Williams truth was a product of discussion and examination. The march to free speech was to be long and arduous, however.
In the history books the 1735 trial of John Peter Zenger, Crown v. Zenger, Andrew Hamilton for the defense, is the birth of a free press. Zenger printed the New York Weekly Journal whose editor James Alexander, an opponent of royal governor William Cosby, accused the governor of being a tyrant who violated New Yorker’s rights. Zenger was charged with seditious libel for printing Alexander’s accusations. Is the Biden administration following in Gov. Cosby’s footsteps by declaring free speech “disinformation”? Listening to Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas’ testimony before the House and then “Minister of Truth” Nina Jankowicz’s tweet, “I shudder to think about if free speech absolutists were taking over more platforms” one must begin to think so.
When two grand juries refused to indict Zenger, Cosby issued an information as an alternative method by which to charge him. Zenger was hauled off to jail where unable to meet an impossibly high bail he languished in his cell until his trial, presided over by James De Lancy, Chief Justice of the New York Supreme Court of Judicature, a Cosby ally. That Zenger could be printing the truth was, by law, legally irrelevant to the charge of seditious libel, just as truth is irrelevant to today’s cancel culture. In the Zenger trial Hamilton, however, carried the day. He argued that liberty itself was at stake, that if what Zenger printed was true it could not be a libel. The jury acquitted, but it would be decades before the principle Hamilton had expounded would be settled law.
Even after the constitution was ratified freedom of the press did not immunize against libel under Common Law. By and large, however, the press exercised freedom of expression even under the threat of prosecution. It would not be until 1805, however, that the principle of the Zenger case was firmly established.
That principle is now under threat from an administration that regards criticism as “disinformation” and critics as seditious “extremists”. If the Disinformation Governance Board establishes itself and like any bureaucracy expands its reach, how long can freedom of speech survive? Will there arise a new John Peter Zenger or Andrew Hamilton? Let’s not find out, disband the board now.
DONATE TO BIZPAC REVIEW
Please help us! If you are fed up with letting radical big tech execs, phony fact-checkers, tyrannical liberals and a lying mainstream media have unprecedented power over your news please consider making a donation to BPR to help us fight them. Now is the time. Truth has never been more critical!
In his civilian career he worked primarily in Army Public Affairs and for the Air Force as historian to the presidential wing in the early Reagan administration and later for Air Force Legislative Liaison covering congressional hearings and assisting in preparing testimony for senior leaders.
His essays and reviews have appeared in the scholarly and popular press including Asian Affairs and the Washington Times. He is co-author, with Ali Wahab, of The Iraqi Royal Family, a Collection of Photographs Recovered from The Ruins of the Zuhur Palace, 2004.
A native New Yorker, he holds a BA with honors in history from Findlay College (Ohio) and an MA in history from The Ohio State University. He is a graduate of the US Army Command & General Staff College and was graduated with distinction US Naval War College with a MA in National Security and Strategic Studies.
- “War crime!” say Dems, history says NO! - December 11, 2025
- The Afghan killer — murder without motive in DC? Not likely - December 2, 2025
- “No Kings”? Are they playing with a full deck? - November 3, 2025
Comment
We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, profanity, vulgarity, doxing, or discourteous behavior. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain fruitful conversation.
BPR INSIDER COMMENTS
Scroll down for non-member comments or join our insider conversations by becoming a member. We'd love to have you!
8 thoughts on “Biden’s Disinformation Governance Board repudiates freedom”
Comments are closed.
IF we let this stand…we’re LIVESTOCK!
Our opinions must match government’s ideology, or we’re put out to pasture! Silenced! If the Constitution means anything, then this is blatantly unConstitutional!
“WHY”? do we need ANYBODY, least of all from-WASHINGTON-to-“tell”-“us”-“what’s”-TRUE-OR-Untrue?We-have-enough-media-&-Jen-Paki-to-tell-us-that!THIS-IS-WHY!-TRUMP-AND-OUR-OWN-BRAINS-can_”tell”-us-this!-WE-“know”-in-our-gut-“THAT”-the-DEMS-have-got-to-go!How-much-more-can-these-BUMS-come-up-with-BEFORE-11/4/22!EASY!-VOTER_FRAUD!
And wasn’t it nice how he tried to sneak in the funding for this useless disinformation female into the Ukraine bill. Folks, write your congressmen, and let them know you do not want to fund this useless office. I think our constitution supercedes it!
As I watch Democrats and even Republicans “debate” whether Nina Jankowicz is the right person to head Brandon’s new “Disinformation Governance Board” the insanity of even having such a “board” is straight out of Orwell’s “1984”. It is worth remembering that while we debate what overlord is in charge or our newest Totalitarian oversight agency, we still have dozens of Americans Illegally and unconstitutionally locked up in a D.C. jail (without due process or bail) for over a year and a half. Soon we will have new “real” riots to protest a “birthing person’s” right to kill their unborn baby. Except now they are calling them Women again? Since the Democrats have previously said that whatever the Supreme Court decides is “the law of the land”, I wonder if these new “insurrectionists” will also go to a D.C. gulag?
This is as INSANE as allowing the turnip in the White House to determine what day it is!
“He argued that liberty itself was at stake, that if what Zenger printed was true it could not be a libel.”
Enter the Disinformation Governance Board which will take it upon itself to decide what is true—and the names of those who disagree will be referred to three-letter agencies. What could possibly go wrong?
Biden and the Democrats are hell bent on destroying everything that is and was ever good in this Country! With this Disinformation Governance Board and now this OH SO COVENIENT leak from The Supreme Court, the Destruction of The Constitution continues! Since Day One, This Demented, Fool of a president and His Administration and the Whole Democratic Party have taken so much of our freedoms away and All of the Members of Congress have stood by and let it happen! And now we will be monitored for “disinformation” aka TRUTH? Biden and Buddies have done nothing but preach lies over and over again. Especially with Covid! And they are still fighting to have the CDC mandate masks again! Forget about going back to that BS! They continue to lie everyday and Jen is the worst! She thinks we are so stupid that we will believe anything she says? Jen – if this Disinformation Board is an extension of President Trump’s Administration, name one member of his board!
I have never felt such Hatred for a President, His Wife, His Administration and the People that put him there! They have tried over and over to break the majority of this country that Do Not want and Did Not vote for any of this, but they can’t and they won’t keep us from standing up and fighting against all the wrongs they have done! They will pay in November‼️
Just more PRECEDENTS for the next R Administration if they use my SCORCHED EARTH Policies! I do believe that biden was installed TO DO the DAMAGE he has in order to COMPLETELY DESTROY any opposition to the LEFTISTS! It’s NOT WORKING as well as they expected since too many of their supporters are SUFFERING TOO!! Oddly, most LEFTISTS don’t like it when their costs escalate so much without a Gov’t handout to OFFset!